Best Local Tea and Coffee in Lancaster, PA: 6 Brands to Buy

If you have a line in your budget for coffee, then this blog is for you. Whether you like your coffee black or mostly cream, or your tea with honey or a sprinkle of sugar, no one can deny the popularity of these two beverages. In fact, tea is the second-most popular drink in the entire world, and coffee is third. 

No matter which you prefer, we’re here to help you find the best local tea and coffee in Lancaster, PA, and where to buy it! Here at Stauffers of Kissel Hill, we believe in the power of supporting local businesses. That’s why we stock amazing products from our favorite local tea and coffee roasters. 

Best Local Tea and Coffee in Lancaster, PA: Roasters

Whiff Roasters

Whiff Roasters is a specialty roaster in Lititz, PA, and has been in business since 1999. And most importantly, they are the primary coffee supplier at Stauffers. They use the highest-quality Arabica beans for their batches for a richer taste and smoother sip. 

They started as a small business called “Spill the Beans.” Adorable, right? As they grew, they started roasting and selling their own coffee beans. Soon enough, they evolved from made-to-order batches to the thriving local business they are today.

But what makes them one of the best coffee brands in Lancaster, PA? The quality and freshness are key, but they also offer a wide variety of coffees. They have the classics, portion packs, single-serve cups, fun flavors, and even seasonal options. You can find a selection of beans, coffee grounds, cups, and flavor samplers in-store at Stauffers.

Lancaster County Coffee Roasters

For more than a decade, this family-owned brand has been roasting small-batch coffee in Lancaster, PA. They are committed to the traditions that make Lancaster County unique—quality and that homemade touch. Every cup is handcrafted, and while their beans are sourced from around the world, each sip brings you back to their roots. 

They sell whole beans, pre-ground coffee, and single-brew cups for your Keurigs. Their inventory includes the classics, plus seasonal options that will make your taste buds celebrate. What makes them especially unique (and one of the best coffee brands in Lancaster, PA) is their locally-inspired flavors, including shoofly pie, stroopwafel, Dutch apple crumbcake, and whoopie pie.

Gerhart Coffee

Gerhart has been roasting specialty coffee in Lancaster, PA since 1880. That’s even before Stauffers’ time! They carefully choose their overseas partners, making sure the workers and environment are treated well at every stage, so you can get the best cup of coffee around. 

They’ve got everything you could want: Light, medium, and dark roast. Espresso. Fair trade and organic coffee. Decaf. Flavored. And even custom roasting options. At Stauffers, we offer a mix of grounds and beans from Gerhart Coffee.

East Indies Coffee

East Indies Coffee began in Philadelphia over 45 years ago, with the goal of becoming the best roaster in the region. The owners traveled around the world, making industry connections in pursuit of this feat. As the company grew, they moved to Lebanon County, PA, right next door to Lancaster! This specialty coffee in Lancaster, PA features beans from the best growing regions around. 

East Indies offers medium, dark, and extra dark roasts, so your cup of joe is exactly how you like it. Coffee lovers like you can buy individual bags of the best local tea and coffee in Lancaster, PA at your local Stauffers of Kissel Hill!

East Indies Tea

East Indies is committed to satisfying your cravings, no matter the beverage. Along with coffee, they also specialize in a large selection of teas, with loyal customers across North America! Whether you love a strong flavor or just want a calming drink, they have just the right pick for you.  

East Indies is one of the best tea brands in Lancaster, PA. They sell black tea, white tea, green tea (including matcha), chai, fruit blends, floral blends, rooibos, mate, and more! You can find a variety of blends at your nearest Stauffers.

Trolley Line Coffee

Trolley Line Coffee started in 2015. While they may be newer to the scene, their products are still top-notch. Their first roastery was located on a farm outside Lancaster, called Fat Cow Coffee Roasters. Then in 2024, they rebranded to Trolley Line Coffee and opened their café in Salunga, PA. 

Each cup of coffee provides flavors you’re sure to love. Whether you’re just getting into coffee or are a lifetime lover, they are one of the best coffee brands in Lancaster, PA.

Best Local Tea and Coffee in Lancaster, PA: Cafes

We get it—sometimes, coffee just tastes better when a barista makes it. If you’re on the hunt for the best local tea and coffee in Lancaster, PA (cafe edition), start with these picks. 

For unique flavors: Aura Little Cafe (Lancaster City)

Spend a day shopping in the city and enjoy a delicious latte, matcha, or boba tea at this Lancaster, PA coffee shop! There’s a walk-up window just off the sidewalk, but pro tip! If you head inside, you can skip the line and order on an iPad. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Iced Pandan Cream Latte

For the best matcha: Square One Coffee (Lancaster City)

Square One offers smooth, strong coffee, plus a variety of hot and iced teas. We especially love their matcha! It’s unsweetened, so it has a delicious earthy taste but can easily be elevated with vanilla or strawberry. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Iced Strawberry Matcha 

For strong coffee: Passenger Coffee (Lancaster City)

This Lancaster, PA coffee shop offers all the staples, along with a variety of tea options for any caffeine drinker. You won’t find super sweet flavors, but you will find simple coffee with an extraordinary taste. 

• SKH drink recommendation: A classic pour-over 

For a speedy drive-through: Latte Luv (Paradise, PA)

For a quick pit stop, we suggest Latte Luv! They have fun flavors and are always quick with your drink. Don’t forget to grab a punch card to earn rewards with every purchase! They also sell Earl Grey tea, peppermint tea, alpine berry tea, matcha, and chai. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Iced Caramel Dream Latte

For the best bang for your buck: Mean Cup (Lancaster, PA)

Located just outside Lancaster City, Mean Cup is a community staple. Here you’ll find locals, families, and college students studying away. They offer lots of flavors, coffee roasts, and tea options for any drinker. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Kiwi Strawberry Iced Tea

For a pick-me-up near our Lititz location: New Holland Coffee (Lititz, PA)

This Lancaster, PA coffee shop sells delicious pastries, sandwiches, coffee, and tea. And the best part? It’s only eight minutes away from our Lititz Fresh Foods store, so you can swing by for a treat on your way home from grocery shopping. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Salted Caramel Cortado 

For a pick-me-up near our Rohrerstown location: Copper Cup (Lancaster, PA)

Just seven minutes from our Rohrerstown grocery store, you can grab a drink at Copper Cup! They also have a drive-through if you want to cruise through without leaving the comfort of your car. They have seasonal flavors, a variety of teas, and breakfast food! 

• SKH drink recommendation: Golden Chai

For a pick-me-up near our Mount Joy location: Trolley Line Coffee (Salunga, PA)

That’s right! Not only do we sell their coffee in-store, but you can also stop by their café for a drink. It’s just seven minutes down the road from our Mount Joy spot, nestled in a restored trolley station and serving some of the best local tea and coffee in Lancaster, PA. 

• SKH drink recommendation: Cappuccino

FAQs About Coffee and Tea in Lancaster

Feed Your Caffeine Cravings

Stauffers is the go-to spot for the best local tea and coffee in Lancaster, PA!

Find A Store

Visit Our Coffee & Tea Experts