Catering

Catering made easy with Stauffers!

Order our appetizers, main courses, sides, and desserts, for more hosting and less hassle for you!

Call or stop by your local Fresh Foods store to order. We kindly request a 24-hour notice when ordering.

Explore easy catering and party tray options below.

We offer a variety of delicious trays for you to pick up and serve at your event. While we don’t deliver or serve on-site, we pack everything with care so it’s ready to go when you are.

Appetizer Party Trays

Olive Tray

Assortment of Peppadews, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Seasoned Calamatas, Bleu Cheese Stuffed Olives, Gigante Green Olives, and Antipasto Delight Salad.

Medium Serves 10-15: $45
Large Serves 15-25: $65

Antipasto Tray

Parmigiano Reggiano, Aged Cheddar and Extra Sharp Provolone Cheeses, Sweet Soppressata, Pepper Salami, Calamatas, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Antipasto Delight Salad and Peppadews.

Medium Serves 10-15: $65
Large Serves 15-25: $95

Gourmet Cheese Tray

“The Cheese Tray to Impress!”
Includes Danish Imported Blue, Fontina, Asiago, Sartori Cheddar with Merlot, and Aged Cheddar. Plus assortment of Dried Apricots, Dried Cranberries, Walnuts & Almonds.

Medium Serves 10-20: $60
Large Serves 20-30: $90

Cheese Cube Tray

Muenster, Aged Swiss, Longhorn, and Sharp Cheddar Cheeses. Served with Local Betsy Lantz’s Mustard.

Medium Serves 12-18: $40
Large Serves 20-30: $60

Cheese and Fruit Tray

Muenster, Longhorn, and Aged Swiss Cheeses with fresh Strawberries, Grapes, and Cantaloupes surrounding a Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar Cheese Ball.

Medium Serves 12-18: $60
Large Serves 20-30: $80

PA Dutch Tray With Bologna

Aged Swiss and Muenster Cheeses plus cubed Ring Bologna or Sweet & Lebanon Bologna with Local Betsy Lantz’s Mustard.

Medium Serves 12-18: $45
Large Serves 20-30: $65

Sushi Trays

Hissho Sushi • Hand Rolled In Store • Available at Rohrerstown and Lititz Only

Sazanka Sushi Tray

Sriracha Party, Philadelphia Roll, and Nigiri.

20 Pieces: $24.99

Honolulu Queen Tray

California Roll, Veggie Roll, Philadelphia Roll, and Healthy Roll.

48 Pieces: $29.99

Osaka Monarchy Tray

California Roll, Nippon, Healthy Roll, Dynamite Roll, Outer Banks, and Nigiri.

40 Pieces: $39.99

Hissho Crunchy Lover Tray

Crunchy Shrimp Roll, Sriracha Party, Wasabi Crunch, Crispy Crab, and Tempura Shrimp Roll.

40 Pieces: $44.99

Yokohama Dynasty Tray

TNT, Tempura Shrimp Roll, Living Color Roll, Outer Banks Roll, and Nigiri.

38 Pieces: $55.99

Kyoto Majesty Tray

California Roll, Sunset Roll, Wasabi Crunch, Sriracha Party, Crispy Crab, Rising Sun Roll, and Nigiri.

54 Pieces: $64.99

Seafood Trays

Peeled, Deveined Shrimp Tray

Two pounds of cooked, peeled, and deveined Shrimp. Served with Cocktail Sauce.

Medium Size Shrimp Approx. 80 Pieces: $45

Large Size Shrimp Approx. 50 Pieces: $50

Jumbo Size Shrimp
Approx. 35 Pieces: $55

Stauffers Pink Shell-On Shrimp Tray

Two pounds of plump and juicy Shrimp, steamed in the Shell for the Best Flavor. Served with Cocktail Sauce. Caught Wild in the USA.

Large Size Shrimp Approx. 50 Pieces: $55

Shrimp & Crab Claw Tray

Served with Cocktail Sauce and a dash of Old Bay Seasoning.

Approx. 25 Large Cooked, Peeled & Deveined Shrimp and 30 Cocktail Crab Claws: $55

Peeled, Deveined Old Bay Seasoned Shrimp Tray

Two pounds of Shrimp seasoned with Old Bay. Served with Cocktail Sauce.

Jumbo Size Shrimp Approx. 35 pieces: $60

Smoked Salmon Tray

Smoked Atlantic Salmon surrounded by Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, and Capers.

Serves 12-14: $65

Salads & Sandwich Trays

Big Salad Bowl

Serves 6-8 | Dressing Not Included

Cobb Salad: $50

Tomatoes, Bleu Cheese, Eggs,
Grilled Chicken, Green &
Red Peppers, Bacon,
Cheddar Cheese

Chef Salad: $45

Ham, Turkey, Tomatoes,
Swiss Cheese, and Provolone Cheese

Garden Salad: $35

Cucumbers, Peppers, Onions,
Shredded Carrots and Tomatoes

Mini-Sub Tray

Served on Club Rolls and made with fresh sliced Meats and Cheeses. All Subs come with Lettuce and Tomatoes with mayo and mustard packets.

Choose from:
· Italian
· Ham and American Cheese
· Turkey and Provolone Cheese
· Roast Beef and Provolone Cheese

Medium 8 Sandwiches: $40
Large 12 Sandwiches: $50

Wrap Tray

Choose from:
· Turkey & Bacon
· Tuna Salad
· Turkey Avocado
· Chicken Caesar
· Chicken Salad
· Chicken Salad BLT

Medium 16 Sandwiches: $60
Large 24 Sandwiches: $80

Mini Sandwich Tray

Served on Martin’s Mini Rolls with mayo and mustard packets.

Choose from:
· Chicken Salad
· Tuna Salad
· Egg Salad
· Sweet Bologna & American Cheese
· Ham & American Cheese

Medium 12 Sandwiches: $20
Large 24 Sandwiches: $40

Sandwich Ring Tray

Served on our fresh baked bread ring with a side of Pickles, Sweet Peppers, Black Olives, Mayo and Mustard packets.

Choose from:
· Italian
· Ham and American Cheese
· Turkey and Provolone Cheese
· Roast Beef and Provolone Cheese

Must have 48 hour notice.
Medium 8-10 Sandwiches: $60
Large 14-16 Sandwiches: $80

Classic Deli Tray

John F. Martin Oven Browned Turkey Breast, Stauffers Medium Well Roast Beef, Sahlen’s Ham off the Bone, Aged Swiss, White and Yellow American Cheese.

Medium Serves 12-18: $55
Large Serves 20-30: $80

Dietz & Watson Deli Tray

Oven Classic Turkey Breast, Uncured Honey Ham, Medium Rare Roast Beef, Baby Swiss and American Cheese.

Medium Serves 12-18: $60
Large Serves 20-30: $90

Grilled Veggie Tray

Chilled Red Pepper Hummus, Carrots, Asparagus, Portabella Mushrooms, Peppers, and Yellow & Green Squash.

Serves 15-20: $65

Catering Favorites

Made from Scratch Lasagna

Choose From:
· Traditional Meat
· Veggie

Serves Approx. 12: $65 Tray

Made From Scratch BBQ

Choose From:
· Hamburger
· Pork

$8.49/ lb.

Italian Meatballs

$9.99/ lb.
Approx. 10 Meatballs per lb.

All White Meat Turkey Breast

Our Turkey Breast is slow roasted.

$10.99/lb.

Fresh Fried Chicken

Hot to Go • Hand-Breaded • We Fry It Fresh!

Drumstick Tray 14 Pieces: $20

Thigh Tray 11 Pieces: $20

Bone-In Breast Tray 6 Pieces: $22

Breaded Wing Tray 30 Pieces: $30

Boneless Chicken Tender Tray 4 lbs. (25 to 30 Pieces): $30

Fried Chicken Party Tray

Hot to Go • Hand-Breaded • We Fry It Fresh!

2 Bone-In Breasts, 6 Thighs, 8 Drumsticks, 8 Wings: $38

Fried Chicken Family Tray

Hot to Go • Hand-Breaded • We Fry It Fresh!

4 Drumsticks, 3 Thighs, 1 Bone-In Breast: $15

Stauffers Roasted Whole Turkey

Local: Raised without Antibiotics on the Sensenig Family Farm in Lititz, PA. The Best You’ll Ever Taste.

Roasted:
Small 12 lb.* $75
Medium 16 lb.* $90
Large 18 lb.* $105

Roasted & Carved:
Small 12 lb.* $90
Medium 16 lb.* $110
Large 18 lb.* $130

Small Serves 8-10. Medium Serves 12-14. Large Serves 16-18. *Weight Before Roasting

Stauffers Roasted Turkey Breast

Local: Raised without Antibiotics on the Sensenig Family Farm in Lititz, PA. The Best You’ll Ever Taste.

Roasted:
Medium 6 lb.* $55
Large 10 lb.* $75

Roasted & Carved:
Medium 6 lb.* $70
Large 10 lb.* $90

Medium Serves 6-8. Large Serves 10-12. *Weight Before Roasting

$99 Turkey Dinner

Boxed & Ready 2 Go • Cold Pick Up Only • Serves 6-8 People

Includes:
· 4 lb. Sliced Turkey Breast
· 1 qt. Turkey Gravy
· 3 lb. Mashed Potatoes
· 2 lb. Stauffers Stuffing
· 2 lb. Green Beans
· 8 pk. Brioche Dinner Rolls
· 9” Stauffers Pumpkin Pie

$99 Ham Dinner

Boxed & Ready 2 Go • Cold Pick Up Only • Serves 6-8 People

Includes:
· 4 lb. Stauffers Glazed Smoked Ham
· 1/2 pt. Stauffers Ham Glaze
· 3 lb. Scalloped Potatoes
· 2 lb. Stauffers Pineapple Stuffing
· 2 lb. Green Beans
· 8 pk. Brioche Dinner Rolls
· Pellman’s Carrot Cake

Beef Roasting Service

Our chefs will season & roast your choice of beef to perfection.

Roasting Service: $30*
Roasting & Carving Service*: $40

*Service Price is for each piece of meat plus the price of meat

Gravy

Choose From:
· Turkey
· Chicken

1/2 Pint: $3.99 • Pint: $5.99 • Quart: $7.99

green beans and mashed potatoes and brussels sprouts e1650285619547

Sides

Sides $7.99/lb.
Baked Corn: Yellow Corn in a creamy sauce.
Candied Yams: Baked in Brown Sugar, Ginger, and Cinnamon.
Mashed Potatoes: Seasoned with Salt, Pepper, Milk, and Real Butter.
Roasted Red Potatoes: Seasoned with Rosemary, Garlic, Thyme, and Oregano.
Roasted Sweet Potatoes: Simply roasted with Sugar, Oil, Salt, and Pepper.

Premium Sides $8.99/lb.
Autumn Roasted Brussels Sprouts: Tossed with Butternut
Squash, Cranberries, Cinnamon, and Pecans in a Maple Flavored Sauce.
Glazed Sweet Potatoes & Apple Medley: Tossed in Brown Sugar and Apple Cider.
Green Beans with Almonds: Seasoned with Salt & Pepper, then topped with Sliced Almonds.
Stuffing: Bread, Celery, Onions, Carrots, Butter, and Chicken Stock.
Pineapple Stuffing: Bread, Pineapple, Eggs, and Butter

Bakery Trays

Custom Sheet Cakes

1/8 Sheet Cake Serves 8-12: $19.99
1/4 Sheet Cake Serves 15-20: $32.99
1/2 Sheet Cake Serves 30-40: $49.99
Full Sheet Cake Serves 70-80: $79.99

Ask our decorators for details on additional charge for fondant, filling, edible image, and cake kits.

FREE Chocolate or Vanilla Smash Cake with purchase of 1st Birthday Cake over $30

Pretzel Bites Tray

Sweet Hawaiian Pretzel Bites
served with Honey Mustard.

6 dozen bites: $30

Grandma Stauffer’s Cookie Tray

Made From Scratch.
Choose 5 varieties from the following:
· Peanut Butter Blossoms
· Chocolate Chip
· Chocolate Crackle
· Coconut Macaroon
· Snickerdoodle
· Oatmeal Cranberry
· Russian Tea Cookies.

40 Count: $40
80 Count: $80

Mini Whoopie Pie Tray

Chocolate with Buttercream or Whipped Filling, Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Filling, Chocolate with Peanut Butter Filling, and Pumpkin with Cream Cheese Icing.

41 Count: $40

Dessert Tray

Mini Cannoli, Mini Eclairs, Baklava, Mini Cream Puffs, and Pecan Bars.

54 Count: $55

Brownie Bite Tray

Delicious chewy bite size Brownies topped with Icing. Includes Buttercream, Peanut Butter, and Fudge Icing. Topped with Sprinkles.

36 Count: $35

Pudding Dessert Party Tray

Choose From:
· Dirt Pudding
· Watergate
· Banana
· Eclair
· Lemon Delight
· Peanut Butter Delight

Serves 12-16: $20

Stauffers Fruit Tart

Made from scratch with a Shortbread Tart Shell and topped with the Freshest Fruit on a bed of Cream Cheese Filling.

Serves 10-12: $24.99

Mini Danish Tray

Mini danish filled with Apple, Cherry, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, Lemon, Raspberry, and Strawberry then drizzled with white icing.

24 Count: $25

Filled Mini Croissants

Flaky Buttery Croissants filled with Angel Cream, Chocolate Bavarian, and Strawberry.

36 Count: $30

Breakfast Tray

Mini Filled Croissants, Mini Danish, Mini Scones, and Mini Muffins.

40 Count: $30

Produce & Fruit Baskets

Classic Fresh Fruit Tray

Honeydew, Cantaloupe, Watermelon, Super Sweet Pineapple, Red Ripe Strawberries, Red and Green Seedless Grapes, and Blackberries.

Choose from Stauffers Raspberry Yogurt or Cream Cheese Marshmallow Dip.

Medium Serves 15-20: $44
Large Serves 20-25: $52

Grand Fresh Fruit Platter

Sliced Red, Yellow & Green Peppers, tender Green & Yellow Squash, Snap Peas, Celery & Carrot Sticks, Broccoli & Cauliflower Florets, Seedless Cucumbers, and mix of Medley Tomatoes.

Serves 20-25: $85

Classic Fresh Veggie Tray

Red and Yellow Peppers, Crisp Celery Sticks, Fresh Cut Cauliflower & Broccoli, Sweet Baby Carrots and Grape Tomatoes.

Choose from Marzetti Ranch or Marzetti Light Ranch Dip.

Medium Serves 15-20: $37
Large Serves 20-25: $47

Grand Fresh Veggie Platter

Sliced Red, Yellow & Green Peppers, tender Green & Yellow Squash, Snap Peas, Celery & Carrot Sticks, Broccoli & Cauliflower Florets, Seedless Cucumbers, and mix of Medley Tomatoes.

Serves 20-25: $85

Fresh Fruit Bowl

An assortment of Sweet Pineapple, Cantaloupe and Honeydew, Red Seedless Grapes topped off with Sliced Kiwi, Strawberries, Blueberries, and Blackberries.

Medium Serves 10-12: $24
Large Serves 12-15: $30