Call or stop by to place your order. Open Every Day 7am-9pm
We kindly request a 24 hour notice when ordering.
Please click on a category below to jump to that section.
Cheese Shop
Olive Tray
Enjoy an international tray with an assortment of Peppadews, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Seasoned Calamatas, Bleu Cheese Stuffed Olives, Gigante Green Olives, and Antipasto Delight Salad.
Medium Serves 10-15…….. $35
Large Serves 15-25…….. $55
Antipasto Tray
An authentic Italian treat featuring bite size pieces of Parmigiano Reggiano, Aged Piave, and Extra Sharp Provolone Cheeses, Sweet Soppressata, Pepper Salami, Seasoned Calamatas, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Antipasto Delight Salad, and Peppadews.
Medium Serves 10-15…….. $50
Large Serves 15-25…….. $85
Grand Gourmet Cheese Tray
“The Cheese Tray to Impress!” Comes with Buttermilk Blue, Wisconsin Fontina, Black Wax Asiago, & Sartori Cheddar with Merlot, and a 5 Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar. Dried Apricots, Dried Cranberries, Candied Walnuts, and Marcona Almonds are also included.
Serves 20-30…….. $85
Cheese Boards
Cheese Boards include 4 Cheeses, Marcona Almonds, Dried Apricots, & Cranberries.
Medium Serves 6-8…….. $35
Large Serves 8-10…….. $45
Choose From:
Italian
Featuring Parmigiano Reggiano, Piave, Pecorino Romano, and Taleggio Cheeses.
Spanish
Featuring Manchego, Idiazabal, Murcia Al Vino, and Campo de Montalban Cheeses.
English
Featuring Barbers Cheddar, Huntsman, Cranberry Stilton, and Cotswold Cheeses.
French
Featuring Brie, d’ Affinois, Cambozola, and Morbier Cheeses.
Deli
Cheese Cube Tray
Includes snack size cubes of Muenster, Aged Swiss, Longhorn, and Sharp Cheddar Cheeses. Served with a Spicy Brown Mustard.
Medium Serves 12-18…….. $35
Large Serves 20-30…….. $55
Cheese & Fruit Tray
Featuring cubed Muenster, Longhorn, and Aged Swiss Cheeses with fresh Strawberries, Grapes, and Cantaloupes surrounding a Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar Cheese Ball.
Medium Serves 12-18…….. $45
Large Serves 20-30…….. $65
PA Dutch Tray
A PA Dutch favorite…featuring cubed Aged Swiss and Muenster Cheeses with your choice of cubed Sweet & Lebanon Bologna, or Ring Bologna. Served with a Spicy Brown Mustard.
Medium Serves 12-18…….. $40
Large Serves 20-30…….. $60
Stauffers Signature Deli Tray
Our finest Oven Browned Turkey, Smoked Ham, and Top Round Roast Beef alongside American and Swiss Cheeses.
Medium Serves 12-18…….. $50
Large Serves 20-30…….. $75
Dietz & Watson Deli Tray
Choose 3 meats from the following: Oven Classic Turkey, Honey Cured Glazed Ham, London Broil, Gourmet Chicken Breast, and Applewood Smoked Ham.
Choose 2 cheeses from the following: Sandwich Swiss, American, Provolone, and Red Wax Cheddar
Medium Serves 12-18…….. $55
Large Serves 20-30…….. $85
Rolls from the Bakery
Kaiser Rolls
A large size roll to build the perfect a sandwich.
Dozen…….. $5.98
Club Rolls
Layer these rolls with fresh meats and cheeses to make an outstanding sandwich.
Dozen…….. $5.98
Party Rolls
These rolls are great for any party. Just the right size for meat and cheese or barbeque.
Dozen…….. $3.99
Pretzel Bite Tray
Philly Style Pretzel Bites served with your choice of Yellow Mustard, Honey Mustard or Spicy Mustard.
5 dozen bites $30
Sushi
Hissho Crunchy Lover Tray
Crunchy Shrimp Roll, Sriracha Party, Wasabi Crunch, Crispy Crab, and Tempura Shrimp Roll.
40 Pieces…….. $39.99
Osaka Monarchy Tray
California Roll, Nippon Favorite, Healthy Roll, Dynamite Roll, Outer Banks, and Nigiri.
40 Pieces…….. $34.99
Yokohama Dynasty Tray
TNT, Tempura Shrimp Roll, Living Color Roll, Outer Banks Roll, and Nigiri.
38 Pieces…….. $49.99
Sazanka Tray
Sriracha Party, Philadelphia Roll, and Nigiri.
20 Pieces…….. $19.99
Honolulu Queen Tray
California Roll, Veggie Roll, Philadelphia Roll, and Healthy Roll.
48 Pieces…….. $24.99
Kyoto Majesty Tray
California Roll, Sunset Roll, Wasabi Crunch, Sriracha Party, Crispy Crab, Rising Sun Roll, and Nigiri.
54 Pieces…….. $59.99
Seafood
“Pink Hopper” Shell-On-Shrimp Tray
Two pounds of plump & juicy Shrimp, steamed in the shell for the best flavor. Served with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon Wedges. Caught Wild in the Caribbean Waters.
Medium Size Shrimp
Approx 75 Pieces………………………………$45
Large Size Shrimp
Approx 55 Pieces………………………………$50
Jumbo Size Shrimp
Approx 35 Pieces………………………………$55
Cooked, Peeled & Deveined Shrimp Tray
Two pounds of cooked, peeled, and deveined Shrimp with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon Wedges.
Medium Size Shrimp
Approx 90 Pieces………………………………$40
Large Size Shrimp
Approx 55 Pieces………………………………$45
Jumbo Size Shrimp
Approx 35 Pieces………………………………$50
Shrimp & Crab Claw Tray
Served with Lemon and Cocktail Sauce and a dash of Old Bay Seasoning.
Approx 25 Large Cooked, Peeled & Deveined Shrimp (1lb.)
30 Cocktail Crab Claws (12 oz.)………………………………$50
Smoked Salmon Tray
Smoked Atlantic Salmon surrounded by Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, and Capers. Served with Lemon Wedges.
Jumbo Size Shrimp
Serves 12-14………………………………$60
Cooked, Peeled, Deveined Old Bay Shrimp Tray
Two Pounds of shrimp seasoned with Old Bay. Served with cocktail sauce and lemon wedges.
Jumbo Size Shrimp
Approx 35 pieces………………………………$50
Salads & Sandwiches
Big Salad Bowl
Cobb Salad
This salad has something for everyone! Loaded with Tomatoes, Bleu Cheese, Eggs, Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Green & Red Peppers, Celery, and Provolone Cheese. Dressing is not included.
Serves 6-8….. $35
Chef Salad
A traditional salad that starts with a blend
of Greens served with Ham, Turkey, Tomatoes, Swiss
Cheese, and Cheddar Cheese. Dressing is not included.
Serves 6-8….. $35
Garden Salad
This salad mix has the freshest
vegetables. Starting with a blend of Greens, including
Peppers, Onions, and Tomatoes. Dressing is not included.
Serves 6-8….. $30
Mini Sub Tray
Served on Stauffers Signature Club Rolls and made with Stauffers Signature Meats and Cheeses. All Subs come with Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions with a side of Mayo and Mustard.
Choose From
Italian: Featuring Capicola, Hard Salami, Genoa Salami, Ham off the Bone, and Provolone Cheese
Ham: Featuring Ham off the Bone and American Cheese
Turkey: Featuring Oven Browned Turkey and Provolone Cheese
Roast Beef: Featuring Roast Beef and Swiss Cheese
Medium
8 Sandwiches $35
Large
12 Sandwiches $45
Two Foot Party Sub
Made on a Fresh Baked Roll using Stauffers Signature Meats and Cheeses. All Subs come with Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions with a side of Mayo and Mustard.
Choose From
Italian: Featuring Capicola, Hard Salami, Genoa Salami, Ham off the Bone, and Provolone Cheese
Ham: Featuring Ham off the Bone and American Cheese
Turkey: Featuring Oven Browned Turkey and Provolone Cheese
Serves 6-8 $30
Wrap Tray
Choose from our delicious Turkey & Bacon, Tuna Salad, Italian, Grilled Chicken Caesar, and Veggie & Hummus Wraps.
Medium
16 – 3” Wraps $55
Large
24 – 3” Wraps $75
Mini Sandwich Tray
Choose from Stauffers’ ham, turkey, roast beef, Tuna Salad or Chicken Salad on Martin’s Potato Rolls with your choice of cheese.
Medium
12 Sandwiches $35
Large
20 Sandwiches $55
Mini Croissant Sandwich Tray
Flaky Buttery Croissants filled with Albacore Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, or Chunky White Chicken Salad.
Medium
12 Sandwiches $40
Large
20 Sandwiches $60
Grilled Veggie Tray
Freshly Grilled Vegetables served chilled with a Red Pepper Hummus. Includes Grilled Carrots, Asparagus, Portabella Mushrooms, Peppers, and Yellow & Green Squash. Approx 4.5 lbs.
Serves 15-20 $60
Sandwich Fixins Tray
Everything to finish your favorite sandwich. Includes Iceberg Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Spinach, Sweet Peppers, and Red Onions.
Medium: Serves 12-18 $25
Large: Serves 20-30 $35
Main Dish
Mac & Cheese
Our Mac and Cheese is rich and creamy, made from an old fashioned recipe. It’s the ultimate in comfort food. Enjoy all the varieties.
Original Half Pan: Serves: 12-15……… $45
Lasagna
Our lasagna is made from layers of Pasta, Cheeses, and Tomato Sauce with the perfect seasoning.
Choose From
Cheese: Loaded with a blend of Mozzarella and
Asiago Cheeses.
Meat: Layered Ground Beef with Onions and Garlic
between layers of Pasta, Sauce, and Cheese.
Veggie: Layered with Fresh Veggies: Red and Green Peppers, Eggplant, Red Onion, Portabella Mushrooms, Squash, and Zucchini.
Half Pan Serves 10-12……… $65
Ribs
Our award winning Ribs are slow roasted to perfection, creating the most tender and delicious flavor in every bite. Covered with Stauffers Signature BBQ Sauce and cut into pieces, they’re finger lickin’ good.
Half Pan Serves 8-10……… $45
Barbeque
There’s nothing like a sweet and tangy barbeque sandwich, and our barbeque is no exception! We use the freshest meat and slow roast it for tenderness. Then it’s topped
off with Stauffers Signature BBQ sauce for the perfect taste.
Choose From Turkey, Hamburger, or Pork
Half Pan Serves 15-18……… $50
Italian Meatballs
Our Tender Meatballs are perfect for any gathering serve in a roll or just by themselves. Cooked in our marinara sauce.
Half Pan Serves 6-8………$45
Hand Carved Turkey Breast
Our Turkey Breast is slow roasted and hand carved for the perfect sandwich or center of the plate.
Half Pan Serves 10-12……… $50
Roasting Services
Our chefs season your turkey with just the right amount of spices. Then we cook your turkey to perfection so it’s tender and juicy. Please let our chefs know if you want the giblets and neck.
Stauffers Signature Turkey
Raised without antibiotics on the Sensenig Family Farm in Lititz, PA. The best you’ll ever taste.
Roasted:
Small 12 lb.* $65
Medium 16 lb.* $80
Large 18 lb.* $95
Roasted & Carved:
Small 12 lb.* $75
Medium 16 lb.* $90
Large 18 lb.* $110
Small Serves 8-10. Medium Serves 12-14. Large Serves 16-18. *Weight Before Roasting
Stauffers Signature Turkey Breast
Raised without antibiotics on the Sensenig Family Farm in Lititz, PA. The best you’ll ever taste.
Roasted:
Medium 6 lb.* $45
Large 10 lb.* $65
Roasted & Carved:
Medium 6 lb.* $50
Large 10 lb.* $70
Medium Serves 6-8. Large Serves 10-12. *Weight Before Roasting
Beef Roasting Service
Our chefs will season & roast your choice of beef to perfection.
$30 Roasting Service
plus price of meat
$35 Roasting & Carving Service
plus price of meat
Sides
Autumn Roasted Brussels Sprouts $7.99 lb
Tender Brussels Sprouts roasted and then tossed with Butternut Squash, Cranberries, Cinnamon, and Pecans in a Maple Flavored Sauce.
Baked Corn $6.99 lb
A simple but delicious blend of White and Yellow Corn in a creamy sauce baked to perfection.
Candied Yams (Seasonal) $6.99 lb
Orange Fresh Yams baked in Orange Juice, Brown Sugar, Ginger, and Cinnamon.
Cranberry Relish (Seasonal) $7.99 lb
Chopped Fresh Cranberries blended with Red Delicious Apples, Navel Oranges, and a touch of Sugar.
Green Bean Casserole $7.99 lb
This essential side for the holidays is available all
year long! Tender Green Beans in a Rich Mushroom
Sauce and topped with Crispy Fried Onions.
Green Beans with Almonds $7.99 lb
Tender Green Beans sauteed in Olive Oil, seasoned with Salt & Pepper, then topped with Toasted Sliced Almonds.
Glazed Sweet Potatoes and Apple Medley (Seasonal) $6.99 lb
This harvest medley features Sweet Potatoes and Apples tossed in a Brown Sugar with an Apple Cider Sauce.
Homestyle Mac and Cheese $5.99 lb
A blend of Creamy Cheeses mixed with Pasta.
Mashed Potatoes $6.99 lb
Raw White Potatoes cooked, then mashed with Salt, Pepper, Milk, and real Butter.
Potato Bread Filling $7.49 lb
A Lancaster County traditional dish. We start with Martin’s Potato Bread then mix Celery, Onions, Carrots, Butter, Chicken Stock, and add Seasonings.
Roasted Red Potatoes $6.99 lb
Perfect small Red Potatoes roasted in oil and seasoned with Rosemary, Garlic, Thyme, and Oregano.
Roasted Sweet Potatoes (Seasonal) $6.99 lb
Tender Sweet Potatoes cut in long wedges and simply roasted with Sugar, Oil, Salt, and Pepper.
Cakes
We decorate it just the way you want it.
Round Cakes
5” Round Single Layer Serves 1-2 $5
8” Round Single Layer Serves 5-6 $13
10” Round Single Layer Serves 8-10 $20
12” Round Single Layer Serves 12-15 $23
8” Round Double Layer Serves 8-10 $25
10” Round Double Layer Serves 16-18 $30
12” Round Double Layer Serves 25-30 $35
Sheet Cakes
1/8 Sheet Cake Serves 6-8 $15
1/4 Sheet Cake Serves 12-15 $25
1/2 Sheet Cake Serves 25-30 $35
Full Sheet Cake Serves 50-60 $55
Cupcake Cakes
1/8 Sheet Cupcake Cake 12 Cupcakes $17
1/4 Sheet Cupcake Cake 20 Cupcakes $27
1/2 Sheet Cupcake Cake 30 Cupcakes $37
Full Sheet Cupcake Cake 60 Cupcakes $57
Specialty Cakes
White Raspberry Cake
Featuring layers of White Cake, Buttercream Icing, and European Raspberry Filling.
8″ Cake Serves 10-12 $30
Grandma Stauffer’s Double Layer Coconut Cake
Made from Grandma Stauffer’s old fashioned recipe. Coconut Cake with Buttercream Icing, and covered in Flaky Coconut.
8″ Cake Serves 10-12 $30
Chocolate Lovers Cake
This is the ultimate Chocolate Cake. Featuring layers of Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Chocolate Buttercream Icing.
8″ Cake Serves 10-12 $30
Desserts
Fruit Tart
Made from scratch with a Shortbread Tart Shell, then filled with a scrumptious Cream Cheese Filling, and topped with the Freshest Fruit.
Mini Serves 2-4 $9.99
Regular Serves 6-8 $19.99
Large Serves 10-12 $24.99
Dessert Tray
Includes Mini Cannoli, Mini Eclairs, Baklava, Mini Cream Puffs, and Pecan Tarts.
54 Count $50
Brownie Bite Tray
Delicious chewy bite size Brownies topped with Stauffers Signature Icing. Includes
Buttercream, Peanut Butter, and Fudge Icing. Topped with Sprinkles.
36 Count $35
Mini Whoopie Pie Tray
Includes Chocolate with Buttercream Filling, Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Filling,
Chocolate with Peanut Butter Filling, and Pumpkin with Cream Cheese icing.
41 Count $40
Grandma Stauffer’s Cookie Tray
Made from scratch just like Grandma Stauffer did! Choose 5 varieties from the following: Peanut Butter Blossoms, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Crackle,
Coconut Macaroon, Snickerdoodle, Oatmeal Raisin, and Russian Tea Cookies.
40 Count $40
80 Count $65
Fruit & Veggies
Classic Fresh Fruit Tray
Prepared with only the freshest fruit selected at the peak of flavor. Fresh cut pieces of Honeydew, Cantaloupe, Watermelon, Super Sweet Pineapple, Red Ripe Strawberries, Clusters of Red and Green Seedless Grapes, and garnished with Plump Fresh Blackberries. Choose from Stauffers Signature Raspberry Yogurt or Cream Cheese Marshmallow Dip.
Medium Serves 15-20 $35
Large Serves 20-25 $45
Grand Fresh Fruit Platter
A variety of hand selected fruits, picked at the peak of flavor. Sliced Pineapple, Cantaloupe, Honeydew, Strawberries, Red Raspberries, Blackberries, Mangoes, and Kiwi. Sprinkled with plump Blueberries and topped with sprigs of Mint.
Serves 20-25 $85
Classic Fresh Veggie Tray
Prepared with an arrangement of the freshest vegetables. Sliced Red and Yellow Peppers, Crisp Celery Sticks, Fresh Cut Cauliflower & Broccoli, Sweet Baby Carrots and garnished with Flavorful Grape Tomatoes.
Choose from Marzetti Ranch or Marzetti Light Ranch Dip.
Medium Serves 15-20 $30
Large Serves 20-25 $40
Grand Fresh Veggie Platter
An assortment of the freshest vegetables prepared for you. Sliced Red, Yellow & Green Peppers, tender Green & Yellow Squash, Snap Peas, Celery & Carrot Sticks, Broccoli &
Cauliflower Florets, Seedless Cucumbers, and mix of
Medley Tomatoes.
Serves 20-25 $75
Fresh Fruit Bowl
An assortment of Sweet Pineapple, Cantaloupe and Honeydew, Red Seedless Grapes topped off with Sliced Kiwi, Strawberries, Blueberries, and Blackberries.
Medium Serves 10-12 $20
Large Serves 12-15 $27
Fruit Baskets
Our fresh fruit baskets are beautifully packed and are a wonderful gift to give and receive! Each fruit basket* is packed by hand, and contains premium quality extra fancy Royal Gala Apples, Seedless Navels & Oranges, Pink Grapefruits and D’Anjou Pears.
*Fruit selections may vary through the seasons.
Bun Basket……$18.99
11 pieces of Fruit plus Grapes.
Red Basket…$29.99
19 pieces of fruit plus Grapes & Jelly.
Large Red Basket…$39.99
33 pieces of fruit plus Grapes.
Tray…….$12.99
10 pieces of fruit.
Wicker Plate……$15.99
11 pieces of fruit.
Fruit Bowl……$22.99
15 pieces of fruit plus Grapes & Jelly.
Fruit Sculpture……$34.99
20 pieces of fruit plus Grapes, Jelly, and a Candy Tin.
Select Fruit Tray…..$59.99
33 pieces of fruit with Grapes, Candy Tin, Jelly and Pineapple on a serving tray.