In our bakery, the scent of a fresh baked apple pie feels like home. And that’s exactly how we like it. Stauffers Signature baked goods are made just like Grandma used to make them… from scratch! We wake up early every day to bring you fresh baked pies, cookies, cakes and other homemade delights. So whether it’s our own baked oatmeal or gourmet quiches, our expert bakers have made each item especially for you to enjoy. Let us help you celebrate any occasion. From birthdays, weddings, or new baby to graduations…our cake decorators will customize the perfect cake! Stop in and see us today.
Stauffers Signature Desserts
Our bakers wake up early to create sweet desserts that satisfy any sweet tooth! Fresh made fruit tarts, slider cakes, crème brûlée, eclairs, cream puffs, cannoli, and baklava are just some of the to-die-for desserts we offer.
Stauffers Signature Cakes
Whatever you’re celebrating we’re happy to be the sweet ending of your party. We offer round cakes, sheet cakes, and cupcake cakes in a variety of sizes with options for cake flavors, icing flavors, and filling flavors.
Order Cakes Online - Rohrerstown
Order your cakes online for pick up at Rohrerstown.
Order Cakes Online - Lititz
Order your cakes online for pick up at Lititz.
Stauffers Signature Pies
Pies are best homemade, so we make ours in store from scratch! Try our real fruit and fruit crumb pies, cream pies, lemon meringue, pumpkin pies, key lime pies, and seasonal favorites like fresh strawberry pie.
Stauffers Signature Cookies
Have you tried Stauffers Signature Cookies? Each cookie is made the way mom would make them… from scratch! We’ve got flavors that will knock your socks off.
Stauffers Signature Quiche
We start with a fresh flaky crust and then add in savory ingredients like ham, sausage, cheese, fresh vegetables, and herbs, and then finally combined with our quiche mixture.
Stauffers Signature Baked Oatmeal
Start your day with our baked oatmeal. We have over 20 varieties to choose from including seasonal flavors and no sugar added options.
Stauffers Signature Bread, Bagels, & Rolls
Cheese bread, English toasting breads, rainbow bread & loaf breads… We have the best tasting breads and rolls for your sandwiches. Made fresh daily seven days a week.
Stauffers Signature Donuts
Our fresh donuts are baked daily in your favorite classic flavors like glazed, iced cake donuts, sugar donuts, and Boston cream to name a few. However we always make sure to add a little spice with a feature flavored donut each month.