Original Bakery
Our Bake Shop features our Signature line of cookies, cakes, cupcakes, pies, breads, breakfast baked goods, donuts, and more desserts! We bake fresh daily, and we stock our Gourmet Service Case with exciting, delicious designs by our talented Cake Decorating team. Need a simple, or elaborate cake for an upcoming event? Complete the Request Custom Cake below, and our Expert Decorators will gladly fulfill your request, however intricate.
Gourmet Dessert Case
Our bakers wake up early to create delicious desserts that satisfy any sweet tooth! Visit our Gourmet Dessert Service Case for fresh made fruit tarts, slider cakes, crème brûlée, eclairs, cream puffs, cannoli, cupcakes, truffles, macarons, and more.
Entertaining Made Easy
From holidays and birthdays, to graduations and retirements, your guests will love our Signature Dessert Trays! Celebrate with Cakes, Cookies, Brownie Bites, Whoopie Pies, and more.
Signature Hand Decorated Cake
Whatever you’re celebrating we’re happy to be the sweet ending of your party. We offer round cakes, sheet cakes, and cupcake cakes in a variety of sizes with options for cake flavor, icing flavor, and fillings.
Local Baked Goodness
We offer a great selection of local favorites in our bakery to give our customers a true taste of Lancaster County. Enjoy our Signature Whoopie Pies, Shoo Fly Pie, Apple Dumplings, and more.
Signature Donuts
Our donuts are fresh baked daily in your favorite classic flavors like glazed, iced cake donuts, sugar donuts, and Boston cream to name a few. Our Bakers create fun designs with tasty flavor combinations for you to enjoy.
Signature Bread, Bagels, & Rolls
Choose from cheese bread, English toasting breads, rainbow bread, loaf breads, and more, all fresh baked daily in our bakery. We offer the finest selection for any meal of the day, made with quality ingredients.
Signature Cookies
Have you tried Stauffers Signature Cookies? Each cookie is made the way Grandma Stauffer would make them…from scratch! From Chocolate Chip, to Coconut Macaroons and Peanut Butter Blossoms, enjoy timeless flavors.
Signature Fruit and Cream Pies
Pies are best homemade, so we make ours from scratch in store! Try our real fruit and fruit crumb pies, cream pies, lemon meringue, pumpkin pies, key lime pies, and seasonal favorites like strawberry.
Signature Quiches
We start with a fresh flaky crust and then add in savory ingredients like ham, sausage, cheese, fresh vegetables, and herbs. Finally, we mix with our Signature quiche batter for that perfect combination.
Signature Baked Oatmeal
Start your day with our Signature Baked Oatmeal! We have over 20 varieties to choose from including seasonal flavors and no sugar added options. Sweet and satisfying!
Signature Muffins
For an on-the-go snack or tasty breakfast, try our selection of fresh baked Muffins! We make Banana Nut, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Chip, Corn, Cranberry Walnut, Double Chocolate, Peach, Pistachio, and Triple Berry.
Pellman Cheesecakes
We have a great partnership with local Cheesecake connoisseurs, Pellman, to offer you their fantastic line of homemade cake goodness. Try their delicious cheesecakes, or dabble in their carrot cake, peanut butter cup triple chocolate, or pumpkin spice cake.